Success in Condition Monitoring

Contemporary Controls' Skorpion Switch Does the Job for Condition Monitoring System

The concept to monitor and detect problematic conditions of machinery is an in-house function in most facilities. Companies are investing in the training of plant personnel plus software and hardware upgrades. Why? Failure of machinery could result in huge production losses with serious environmental and safety implications, not to mention the high costs incurred when unplanned shutdowns arise.

Condition monitoring is a recognized term describing vibration monitoring systems. These systems are employed to pinpoint bearing wear or damage, machine unbalance, misalignment and other typical machine faults.

There is a powerful incentive to monitor machines because the majority of them are accountable for considerable revenue, generally between $500,000 to $1,000,000 per day-meaning a downed machine can be costly, even if inoperable for a few hours. To aggravate this issue, not all machines are available from stock or can be easily replaced, and delivery times for new machines can range from days to several months, creating a larger challenge for the plant manager.

However, advances in technology offer new choices for plant managers and have changed the direction of condition monitoring since the 1990s. In the opinion of some, the world of condition monitoring has matured from an application standpoint, and as of late, is used to enhance product quality and production output, in addition to monitoring asset health.

Given the idea behind condition monitoring, let's examine one company's recent development in machinery maintenance. One Swedish manufacturer of rolling element bearings, SKF, saw the opportunities in this concept. The company's electronics group, SKF Condition Monitoring, is very influential.

It is valued as a global supplier of hardware and software used for condition monitoring of vibration levels on rotating machinery.

"Condition monitoring is a term describing the vibration data acquisition systems that typically belong with an SKF Asset Efficiency Optimization Program, i.e., where these systems are employed in conjunction with other SKF products and services to identify machine problems and bearing defects," explains Wane Wier, Manager-Applications Engineering Group, SKF Reliability Systems in San Diego, CA.

As part of their customers' maintenance program, SKF's customers use an online surveillance system. SKF has the largest number of installations of this type in operation around the world. Wier says the system is a distributed data acquisition system consisting of hardware and vibration analysis software to monitor machinery around the clock. This is essential to the early detection of developing defects or problems, which if left alone, could result into a catastrophic machine failure.

SKF's previous online system, called the Local Monitoring Unit (LMU) was released more than a decade ago. Wier comments, "It is a fine system, but some of the electrical components are no longer available." With this realization, SKF came forth with a more advanced and more modular data acquisition system in late 2003 called the Multilog Condition Monitoring Unit (CMU). The CMU was designed to replace the LMU, with improved features and performance characteristics. With its release, the company's online system could now reside on an Ethernet LAN. Wier states that the CMU would function with just about any commercial hub, repeater, or switch as part of its network. "However, we needed a device that would operate well in an industrial environment," explains Wier. He says SKF researched various suppliers of Ethernet switches and found Contemporary Controls, a manufacturer of networking equipment in Downers Grove, Illinois. Wier and the other SKF engineers were pleased with the features of Contemporary Controls' new five-port Skorpion Ethernet switch (the EISK5-100T). Although the market segments for SKF's online systems are vast, the EISK5-100T has only been utilized in the Pulp and Paper and Mining segments.

The LMU System

In the past, the LMU employed an RS-485 LAN with a proprietary communications protocol, which for installations larger than 10 LMUs and long cable lengths (up to 6,000 ft. of shielded, twisted-pair cabling), is troublesome to set up. The reason being is the nature of the RS-485 LANs, and the need to use resistive terminations in order to equalize any impedances caused by long cables.

Wier says the RS-485 in the LMU was implemented using a unique FM/Manchester-encoding scheme, along with a bit-oriented protocol, using two discrete frequencies-22 kHz and 448 kHz. "It was chosen because it had better noise immunity," explains Wier. Furthermore, the proprietary protocol made it difficult if not impossible to use most off-the-shelf transceivers and protocol analyzers because they couldn't see or interpret the signals. And converting to another communication medium like fiber optics wasn't simple. "Actually, we did do it," says Wier, "but it was tricky to get it to work and it required extra circuitry. Again, the problem was that not all devices off-the-shelf would operate. Also, few companies manufactured RS-485 to fiber optic transceivers. The CMU made it easier to use fiber optics, since 10BASE-T to fiber optic transceivers are readily available off-the-shelf."

The Advantages of Ethernet

With the CMU, SKF engineers witnessed the many advantages of Ethernet technology. The list of advantages exceeded their expectations.

  1. The company's engineers no longer expressed concern about LAN terminations.

  2. Online systems would be able to survive on existing plant networks, eliminating the costly task of installing an entire new set of communication lines.

  3. Converting from 10BASE-T to wireless, fiber optics,etc., is easily accomplished with existing off-the-shelfequipment.

  4. Faster communication baud rates-indicating largerinstallations take less time to transfer significantamounts of data from the system to the host PC.

  5. Resident IT departments comprehend Ethernet!

Savings Incurred in Online Systems

Wier continues by saying that for those companies that have downsized, condition monitoring via online systems becomes priceless because individuals do not have to walk out and retrieve the data by hand, since the data is automatically collected. "A single online system with 32 channels can save nearly four hours daily-two hours to walk the route with data collection twice a day." The CMU is most valuable when data needs to be collected in extreme hot temperatures or in dangerous areas (exemplified by the dryer section of a paper machine) and therefore, plant personnel do not have to be exposed to these circumstances.

The EISK5-100T Switch

In this application, the EISK5-100T switch provides Plug and Play (PnP) Ethernet connectivity for the CMU. Utilizing switching technology, the Skorpion switch provides 10/100 Mbps shielded RJ-45 ports. Each port supports the auto-negotiation protocol in order to select data rate, duplex and flow control.

The Skorpion switch addresses a key issue-convenient mounting in control panels where DIN-rail space is at a premium. Office-grade equipment is intended for desktop operation requiring a separate power supply that needs to be powered from a 120 VAC outlet. This usually means a shelf must be constructed to mount the unit and a duplex receptacle to be installed inside the control panel. This device is intended for sub-panel mounting and can be powered from the same control transformer that is used to power the other equipment in the control cabinet, making installation neat and reliable. According to Wier, this switch helped to define the level of success for the CMU. The Skorpion switch is shown inside the CMU.

  1. Specifications had to be at least as good as the CMU, which is 55ºC. The EISK5-100T is rated for 60ºC. "We had plenty of spare power from our supplies within the CMU-near 750mA," indicates Wier. "We would require a switch that would consume as little as possible. After measuring the current consumption, we found it to be only 70 mA with a 24 V supply."

  2. Each port of the switch creates a new collision domain, permitting CMUs to be daisy-chained past the four-hub restriction.

  3. Wall space is a concern among the company's customers. "Space is limited in the CMU; it measures 600 mm x 600 mm x 200 mm," says Wier. Wier emphasizes the narrow, DIN-rail footprint of the EISK5-100T allowed SKF to install the switch in the CMU without having to provide a separate enclosure, or even re-design the CMU.

  4. Wier considers the ability to write identification tags, one for each port, directly on the switch to be beneficial. "Usually, field technicians are equipped with handheld units that print out rugged labels (tags) that attach to each end of a given cable."

  5. With the switch installed directly in the CMU, field technicians can walk up with a laptop in hand and use a standard Ethernet patch cable to plug into one of the extra ports on the switch, servicing not only that CMU, but all the CMUs on the LAN. The alternative would have been to use a crossover cable and connect directly with the CMU-meaning each CMU must be serviced one-by-one at its own location.

A Typical Installation

Generally speaking, the installation scenario will differ. Figure 1 is a diagram for a typical installation on a paper machine. Wier states that the length of a paper machine can be as long as a football field and as tall as a three-story structure-meaning that the overall length of the LAN can be 500 ft. or more. The switching technology of the EISK5-100T makes it easy to not only daisy-chain CMUs, but accommodates this overall LAN length with the 100 m segment restriction of 10BASE-T.

The EISK5-100T switches can be mounted inside the CMU or outside the CMUs in a separate enclosure. (Enclosures are designed to withstand harsh environments, particularly the hot and humid areas surrounding the machine.) Wier says CAT5, CAT5e, or CAT6 cabling from the RJ-45 connectors on the CMU motherboard are used to attach to the switch. Lengths are three ft.

 

In case the switch is servicing multiple CMUs, the switch can reside in a separate enclosure. Cable lengths from one CMU to another will be different, maybe a few feet to 50 ft. or more. Wier says that sometimes routers co-exist on the network. "I've seen routers with 10/100BASE-T ports with fiber optics to go from the machine back to the control room. We recommend using a single router between our CMU installation and the rest of the plant network."

Multiple host PCs and multiple client PCs may be positioned anywhere in the system architecture. To generate reports, the host PC utilizes SKF's software known as SKF Machine Analyst. Wier says reports can list just about anything; they are customizable. SKF has some built-in report templates that include Last Measurement reports, Overdue reports, History, Exception, etc.

Closing

For more information on SKF contact: SKF Reliability Systems, 5271 Viewridge Court, San Diego, CA 92123. Phone: (858) 496-3400 and website address: http://www.skfcm.com.

What about the data rate of the traffic? Wier responds by saying that utilization depends on what devices (i.e., company PCs) exist on the network, how many, and what they're transferring. "TCP/IP is collision-sensitive. If the LAN has only the host and CMUs, then utilization is maximized because no more than one CMU can communicate at a time.," says Wier.

Wier concludes that it has been great working with Contemporary Controls and SKF says it's important to have a consistent supply. "Very important. Our systems are heavily-tested, and any changes require complete re-testing-simply to ensure that a modification in one part of the system doesn't affect any other part of the system. In addition, we do implement a just-in-time system for ordering parts and delivering our systems. Accurate quotes on lead times are crucial not only to satisfy delivery requirements, but also to help reduce inventory carrying expenses."